Click on one of the people below to find out more information.

  • Hayden Reynolds
    General Manager and Owner/Principal
    (860) 434-0028

    G. Hayden Reynolds, Jr., GM and Owner/Principal believes successful customer relationships start with forthright communication and genuine interest in customers' needs and desires. He wants Reynolds' customers to be happy, he wants them to win, and he tailors the company's sales and marketing strategies to this purpose.

    A University of Connecticut graduate with a degree in business administration, Hayden joined the business in 1995 in auto sales and over time grown into his position of today. Affable, respectful and animated, he's ardent about his work and infuses all the Reynolds team with his enthusiasm. 

    Hayden is also passionate about the history, future and preservation of the Connecticut River, known for its beautiful vistas and teeming wildlife. He serves on the Connecticut River Museum's Board of Trustees.

    Hayden lives in Lyme with his wife, Emily, Daughters, Lillian, Charlotte and Tess and Golden Retrievers, Hudson and Cutter, whom you might get the chance to meet in the Subaru Showroom. He enjoys the outdoors and when not working is likely bow hunting, fishing or boating on the CT river and Long Island Sound.

  • Kathryn Wayland
    CEO and Controller
    (860) 434-0028

    Kathryn Reynolds Wayland, vice president and controller knows customers by name, enjoys sharing stories with them and making them feel at home.  She's proud of the Reynolds' history and believes impeccable customer service is the key to its 150-plus years of growth and achievement.  In 1995, Kathryn graduated from Cornell University with a B.S. in landscape horticulture and she spent several years afterwards honing her skills.  She joined the company in 1999 as a Subaru service department advisor.  Kathryn moved into her present position in 2001 and thrives on fostering a strong work ethic among the Reynolds team and building strong relationships with customers. Currently, she is a committee member of Troop 26 Boy Scouts, as well as, a member of the Board of Finance for the town of Lyme.  She lives in Lyme, Connecticut with her husband, Mark, and their children, Laura Lee and Ted.  They have fun touring in their restored 1926 Model T Ford and spending summer weekends on Tedlee, their 1965 Lyman sleeper. 

  • Nora A. Walters
    General Sales Manager
    (860) 434-0028 Ext 210

    Nora Walters,General Sales Manager, has been in the Automotive Industry for over 30 years.  She was born and raised in Connecticut.  Growing up, she spent many of her summers at her family's cottage by the shore in Guilford.  

    Loving this area is what brought her to the Shore line to live. Now residing in East Lyme with her husband Clayton, boys Jack, Maxwell and Mason, bonus daughter Addison, as well as, their German Shepherd Bodie and Mini Goldendoodle Lily (coming soon 2/27/22).  Clayton's older children are successfully living their dreams.  Amanda in Boston and James in East Lyme with his wife.  

    In her spare time she enjoys the beach, reading, boating, gardening and spending time with her family.

  • Charlie Mannix
    Sales Manager
    8604340028 Ext 214

    Charlie came to Reynolds' Subaru with the new building in 2018 and has spent his life in the car business. He lives in Madison with his wife, Erin and their four children, Emma, Charlie III, Eloise, and crazy Helen. Life isn't crazy enough, so they all enjoy playing with their 3-year-old Bichon, Ollie and are all very excited for a new puppy coming in the summer!

  • Don Metivier
    Business Manager
    8604340028 Ext 216


    Don, business manager, has been living in Waterford CT his entire life. Living in Waterford and married to his longtime best friend, Valerie. Don and Valerie had been through school together since kindergarten. They have known each other since they were 5 years old. Raising 2 kids, Chandler who has recently started his first year in high school and Ada, she is in her 2nd year in middle school. Don also has a small yorkie, Reese who is 3 years old.

                    Don has grown up in the auto industry. He started washing cars at the age of 10 on Saturdays. When he started selling cars, it was at a new car store in 1995 in Norwich CT and has learned every aspect of a dealership. He has moved up through the "ranks" from a salesperson to a general manager and everything in between. Don prides himself on customer service. He would rather make friends with customers rather than "just selling cars". He was mentored by his hero & best friend, his father, Mike who had worked more than 45 years in the car business.

                    Since Don has started at Reynolds, he can't believe that he hadn't started here 20 years ago. The true story of a family owned and operated business. The Reynolds family goes above and beyond to make their employees feel valued and appreciated and most of all "part of the family".

  • Keith Nye
    Business Manager
    8604340028 Ext 203

    Keith has been working in the car business serving New London and Windham County for 17 years. He is from Sprague where he has been raising his two children, Kevin and Brianna with his wife Bianka. Outside of work is all about family time and building memories. They enjoy hiking, camping, fishing and soccer.

  • Logan

    Logan passed away peacefully at home with Hayden and his girls Labor Day weekend  2020.

    We love him dearly and will miss him.

  • Hudson & Cutter

  • Sandy Spencer
    Certified Sales Consultant
    (860) 434-0028 Ext. 205

    After fifteen years in a dental career, Sandy felt compelled to switch gears.  With her infectious smile and love of people she decided to try her hand at auto sales.  Now, with over ten years experience, she is as enthusiastic about her job as she was when she first started!  Sandy grew up in Clinton, and spent most of her life living on the shoreline.  In her spare time she enjoys cooking, exercising, sports, the beach, and just spending time with family and friends.

  • Bobbi Anne Ward
    Certified Sales Consultant
    (860) 434-0028 Ext. 207

    Bobbi-Anne also known as Bobbi, joined our Subaru sales team in February 2014. Her love for cars and people makes for the perfect fit. Originally from Waterford, she currently lives in Lyme, CT with her blended family; including their beloved Labradors Merry and McGee. Having a tight knit family throughout Connecticut keeps her busy. When she isn't busy, she enjoys spending time with her husband Ray, fishing, camping, and finishing home improvement projects. Stop in and chat with Bobbi!

  • Jim Lockhart
    Certified Sales Consultant
    (860) 434-0028 Ext. 213

    Jim joined the Reynolds' team in 2015 after 20+ years in outdoor industry with Eastern Mountain Sports, and North Cove Outfitters. He is a Subaru enthusiast from way back having purchased his first one used in 1984! Jim lives in Old Saybrook with his wife and teenage son. He is an avid outdoors person, spending his free time with his family enjoying the beach, cycling, hiking, and snowboarding. He also enjoys cooking and homebrewing.

  • Jen Segal
    Certified Sales Consultant
    8604340028 Ext 232

    Jen lives in East Lyme and has one daughter, Lila. She has been in the auto industry for a number of years. She loves to run and has been to Las Vegas this past year to run a marathon. If you ever need a suggestion for a book, just ask Jen, as she is also an avid reader!

  • Chris Rooke
    Certified Sales Consultant
    8604340028 Ext 204

    Chris joined the Reynolds' team in 2018 coming from the retail food industry and has past experience in real estate, investment banking, and spent several years as a gourmet pizza chef. Customer service and satisfaction is #1 in his book. Chris is also a lover of cars and has owned a total of 26 different vehicles including 5 Subaru's, of course! In his spare time Chris enjoys doing projects for friends and family and boating on Long Island Sound. He also dabbles with oil on canvas painting of the ocean and landscapes.

  • Keith Sikora
    Subaru Service Manager
    (860) 434-0028 Ext. 220

    Keith brings over eight years of service experience to our Subaru Service Team.  He is completely committed to keeping your customer satisfaction rating at 100%.  He is always smiling, happy to see you and happy to serve you.  His honesty, reliability and integrity completely encompass the Reynolds' philosophy.  In his free time, Keith and his son Ryan can be found fishing and playing sports.

  • Bryan Manchester
    Service Advisor
    860.434.0028 Ext 228

    Bryan, originally from our local community of Old Lyme, now resides in Mystic, CT. He has proven himself to be a wonderful asset to Reynolds' by running the express service center, cutting down the time of services significantly and recently promoted to service advisor. 

    An alum of Three Rivers Community College, Bryan enjoys spending his free time problem solving, visiting new places with friends and family, doing jiu-jitsu and MMA.

  • Jim Wilkos
    Service Advisor
    860-434-0028 Ext 221

    Jim lives in nearby Old Saybrook and is an all around car guy who has been in the automotive industry for over 30 years. When not working he can be found enjoying the great outdoors. He is an avid hiker, adventure race competitor, motorcyclist, and loves boating the CT River & LI Sound.

  • Robert Fedus Jr.
    Service Advisor
    8604340028 X225

  • Max Griggs
    Express Service Writer
    860-434-0028 X223

  • Rodney Albert
    Foreman-Subaru Master Certified Technician

  • Matt Venetianer
    Subaru Certified Technician

    Matt joined the Reynolds' team in 2012 as an Automotive Service Technician.  Matt trained at the Porter & Chester Technical Institute, majoring in Automotive Technology.  After 14 years of experience with Saab, he joined the Reynolds' team.  Since joining our state of the art repair facility, Matt has been committed to continue with his training and education and has become fully Subaru Certified.  He grew up on the CT Shoreline and resides locally.   During his free time he can most often be found with his family.

  • Eric Cost
    Subaru Master Certified Technician

    Eric, a Senior Master employee for Subaru, attended the CT School of Electronics. With over ten years of Subaru-specific experience, Eric is very knowledgeable about all things Subaru. In his free time, he enjoys hiking, biking, quadding, and spending time with his girlfriend and dog. 

  • Ray Pecoraro
    Subaru Technician

  • Wes Boxwell
    Subaru Certified Technician

    Wes, a longtime resident of the Essex- Deep River area, is in the process of the noteworthy accomplishment of getting Subaru- certified. In his free time, Wes enjoys spending time with his children, riding his motorcycle, and even volunteering his time to coach little league in his area. 

  • Kenneth Kirkup
    Subaru Technician

  • Kevin Hawley
    Subaru Technician

  • Matthew Shafer
    Subaru Technician

  • Karl Lehr
    Subaru Technician

  • Don Berry
    Subaru Express Technician

    Don, born and raised in nearby Norwich, CT, has been around cars for most of his life. His affinity for all things automotive makes him a great addition to the Reynolds' team. In his free time, Don enjoys to spend time with his family, go hiking, and go to the beach

  • Michael Peckham
    Subaru Express Technician

  • Luke Hoffman
    Express Service Tech

  • R.J. Cummings
    Subaru Express Technician

  • Spencer Harvey
    Subaru Express Technician

  • Ronan Phimister
    Subaru Express Technician

  • Monica Mills
    Parts Manager
    8604340028 Ext 227

    Bringing seven years' experience in the used auto industry, Monica joined our team as a Parts Advisor. Once Marty announced his retirement she quickly transitioned from advisor to Manager. Monica has two daughters, a grandson and a granddaughter on the way. Often you might see Monica out dining with her grandson, whom has a fetish for seafood! She also enjoys anything outdoors, from a long hike to an exhilarating motorcycle ride. Monica also embraces our Love Promise in her daily life, often cooking for those left fortunate and donating her time and talent to help anyone in need.

  • Dreamoritza Shrader
    Parts ADvisor

  • Chelsea Teague
    Parts Advisor
    860.434.0028 Ext 222

    Chelsea loves to keep busy. When she was twenty-two,  she left her home in Ithaca, NY to move to a house in Connecticut. She bravely purchased a home, sight-unseen with her savings from working two jobs throughout her college years. Since then, she met her fiancé whom she decided to start dating with the flip of a coin, opened her own thrift store in a shopping mall with one of her closest friends, and adopted a little wiener dog named Iggy. Additionally, she plays bass guitar in a goth-rock band and countless hours of Dungeons and Dragons. After almost a decade of working in retail, Chelsea is happy to have made the change to join the Subaru family as a Parts Advisor.

  • David Pegnataro
    Parts Counter Associate
    860.434.0028 Ext 229

    Dave has resided in Old Lyme his whole life. He graduated from Mitchell College. He is new to the auto industry but is picking it up. 

    He enjoys spending his free time playing soccer and fishing. He especially loves crabbing with his dad on the river right by where he grew up.

  • Jessica Legein
    Office Assistant
    860.434.0028 Ext 211

    Jessica graduated from Lyme-Old Lyme High School and her family owned the beloved Hallmarks ice cream shop. She has a pup named Baxter who loves to cuddle and eat pillows.

  • Christine Carlson
    Title Clerk
    860.434.0028 Ext 231

    Christine worked in the dental field for 19 years and decided to take a chance and try something new. She made the right choice and loves working at Reynolds'. In her spare time she enjoys spending time with her husband and two dogs, Ollie and Rupert. They all love the outdoors especially in the winter.

  • Mollie Kenney
    Marketing & Human Resources
    (860) 434-0028 X217

    With a bit of a mixing bowl of a background, Mollie has recently taken on her passion for marketing. She enjoys baking and watching hockey in her free time.

  • Nancy Meinke

  • Jerome Cushman
    Detail Department Manager

    Jerome is new to the car business, but his quick learning and hard work have made him an asset to us here at Reynolds'. He enjoys making music, exercising, and reading in his free time

  • Steven Hawes
    Auto Detailer

    Steven truly enjoys his job here at Reynolds detailing cars. His hobbies include fishing, craft beer, and playing videogames with his friends.

  • Johnnie Phatha
    Auto Detailer

  • Anaia Oquendo
    Subaru Detailer

  • Kevin Mascaro
    Lot Attendant

  • Joe Barlow
    Retired Subaru Sales

    Congrats Joe on your retirement.  We are going to miss your humor.

    You bring a smile to everyone you meet.

    Joe is enjoying his home life with his beautiful wife Linda.
    They enjoy spending time with there son, daughter-in-law and new granddaughter. You might see them on the golf course, camp ground or playing pickleball. Retirement never looked so good:)

  • Marty Radomski
    Retired Parts Manager
    (860) 434-0028 Ext. 222

    Best of luck Marty!!!! We will miss you.  Retired December 2019.

    Marty has been an integral part of the Reynolds' Subaru Parts & Service department for over 20 years!  Marty is our Parts Manager, and somehow knows just about everyone who walks through the door, and he even knows their driving habits, mileage, and other miscellaneous information.  Marty is extremely honest, hardworking, and responsible. He and his wife Molly live in Deep River, and have two children, Joe & Kevin.

  • Marcia Harriman
    Retired Service Advisor
    (860) 434-0028 Ext. 221

    Marcia has retired!

    Marcia joined Reynolds' Subaru as a service advisor after many years of  experience in customer service. She resides in East Lyme. She has two daughters, Meredith and Joy. 

    Her hobbies include kayaking, cooking, editing novels, helping to organize her high school reunion every five years, and reading.  She loves to travel - has explored many different countries, islands, and states. 

    Come in and schedule your auto service with Marcia!

  • Charlie Miller
    Retired Subaru Master Certified Technician

    Charlie is retired! Enjoy Charlie...we will miss you:)

    Charlie is a true lover of Subaru's. His job is his hobby, he collects motorcycle and cars, and both his Subaru's have over 200k miles. He has 3 awesome kids and 5 grandchildren. He has a passion for riding bicycles and has done 5 Closer to Free rides, raising over 4,000 dollars for Yale Cancer Center.

  • Julian Muller
    Lot Attendant